CAMDEN, NEW JERSEY
![]()
Congregation
Beth El
Park Boulevard &
Belleview Avenue
![]()
Last Updated Tuesday, November 25, 2008
![]()
|
Camden is well known for its ethnic communities. The large Polish, Italian, Irish, German, and Jewish communities played a great role in Camden's history in the 19th and first part of the 20th century, while Black and Puerto Rican families have given the city much of its recent flavor. There are other, lesser known ethnic groups that have made up the fabric of the city's life over the years. Greeks, Armenians, and Ukrainians grouped together in the city in Camden's growth years. More recently, Mexicans, Vietnamese, Jamaicans, Dominicans, Haitians, and Koreans have come to the city to live and seek the American dream. Congregation Beth El was Camden's first Conservative synagogue, representing one of American Judaism three main movements. The congregation built and occupied a wonderful synagogue and school building on Park Boulevard, opposite Farnham Park, after World War I, which it occupied until 1968, when the new building on Chapel Avenue in Cherry Hill was occupied. The Beth El buildings was used by the Parkside Catholic School in the early 1970s, and were renamed St. Bartholomew's Roman Catholic School within a few years. The buildings were torn down around 2000 to make way for the Boys and Girls Club building donated by Camden native Louis Katz, the owner of several professional sports franchises. In March of 2006 I received a package of information from Rabbi David Herman, the son of Cantor Louis Herman, whose voice for many years inspired the faithful at prayer, and Mrs. Yetta Herman, who was involved for many years in Jewish education at Beth El. Besides David's own story of people and events at Beth El and in Parkside, there were copies of the 80-plus pages of Beth El's history through 1970, which you will find on this page. This will obviously take a bit of time to scan into the website, but in time it will be presented here in its entirety. Phil Cohen |
![]()
|
IN THE BEGINNING "In the Beginning G-d created Beth El as a dream in the hearts of men". These words formed the opening sentence of Beth El's Golden Jubilee Proclamation read by President Martin Odlen at Kol Nidre services September 21, 1969 (5730). Who were the men who had the dream? Certainly Benjamin Natal, Camden's first Jewish lawyer, was not only one of the dreamers but also one of the great organizers and activators who helped turn the dream into reality. In the opinion of many, he might rightfully be called the "Founding Father" of the congregation. Before Mr. Natal's involvement in the Beth El dream, we can trace his communal activities back to 1912. Under his leadership, a group filed a certificate of incorporation in 1912 for the Young Men's Hebrew Association of Camden. "To promote and embrace the broadest cultural and social efforts and diversion, strongly emphasizing Jewish values, encouraging every ennobling aspiration, improving the intellectual and moral faculties, thereby bettering the Jewish community and maintaining it at its highest standard." The first meetings of the YMHA were on the second floor of Abe Furhman's furniture store at Broadway and Division Street. Soon after they moved to the Dannenhower Building at the Southwest corner of Broadway and Kaighn. On
May 21, 1917 the YMHA chartered it's first real building at 572 Walnut
Street. While
in the Dannenhower
Building,
services were conducted on the High Holidays. These services were
"modern" compared to the Orthodox services held in the
existing synagogues. Later these services were held at the Towers
Theater. After the YMHA was built on Walnut
Street near Sixth Street, services were conducted in the
"Y" Auditorium. A cantor was brought in from Philadelphia or
New York. Amongst the leaders of these modern services were Harry
Nurock, Israel
Weitzman, Sig
Schoenagle and Abe Fuhrman. It is not clear to what extent Ben Natal was part of the congregation at the YMHA but in 1915, he sent letters to the Jewish community of Camden with regard to forming, a "modern Orthodox synagogue" to be called Rodeph Sholom.
1920
On October 3, 1920, a meeting was held in Mr. Natal's law office for the purpose of organizing a new congregation in Camden. The twenty-five men present included Harry Barroway, Dr. Otto Reiter, Reuben Pinsky and Manny Pearl. Each of the latter four contributed fifteen dollars and the dream became real. According to Herman Natal in an interview published in the "Voice" September 1951, others at that meeting were Louis Cades, Kolman Goldstein, Harry Teitelman, Herman Natal, Louis Berkowitz, Morris Handle and A. I. Rovner. Jacob Leventon attended a subsequent meeting.
1921 The new location for Beth El at Park Boulevard and Belleview Avenue was secured in May of 1921 for the price of eight thousand dollars. Realizing that a large synagogue building would take quite some time to finance and build, the directors decided to first erect a School Building that would also serve as a temporary synagogue. Eventually, when the membership and funds would increase, a large synagogue building would then be built. Construction of the school building began in July of 1921 and was completed in time for the High Holy Days of that year, which began on October 3rd. By the time the building was completed, the congregation numbered close to fifty families. Before the High Holy Days of 1921, Beth El had elected an "English-speaking Rabbi". Rabbi Solomon Grayzel was a graduate of Columbia University and had just been ordained by the Jewish Theological Seminary of New York. The Cantor who officiated with Rabbi Grayzel at those first High Holiday services was Ephraim Fogelnest from New York. On
November 1, 1921, Beth El was officially incorporated by the state of New
Jersey. On the Certificate of Incorporation, dated November 1, 1921, the
founders were:
At
the invitation of Rabbi Grayzel, the wives of members were invited to a
meeting on November 1, 1921, for the purpose of organizing a Sisterhood.
Mrs. Benjamin Natal (Minnie) became Sisterhood's first President. The
School Building-Temporary Synagogue, was dedicated on November 13, 1921.
It had been put up at a cost of $15,000. Taking part in the dedication
service were Rabbi Mortimer J. Cohen of Philadelphia's Beth Sholom, Rabbi
Max Klein and Judge John
B. Kates of the Camden County Common Pleas Court. The Dedication
Sermon was given by Rabbi Grayzel who was listed in the program as
"minister of the congregation". The service also included a
violin solo by Mr. Julius Cades. In the Dedication Service Book there were
listed the names of the officers and directors of the congregation, the
building committee, the officers of Sisterhood and the Beth EI Junior
Auxiliary or Young People's Auxiliary whose president, Harry Berkowitz,
was to become a future president of the congregation. It is interesting to
note that on the invitation to the dedication of this, Beth El's first
school building there was a note on the left-hand comer that read-"no
children admitted". A Sunday School and a daily Hebrew School with
"Englishspeaking teachers" were organized in the fall of 1921.
Rabbi Grayzel also began teaching Beth El's first confirmation class. Morris
Handle was reelected President of the Congregation. 1922 The first issue of the Synagogue's news bulletin was published on April 12, 1922. It was called the "Beth-Elite" and consisted of two pages. The bulletin appeared just before Passover and gave the holiday schedule of services. The front page reported a minstrel show having been put on at Beth El by the Camden Young Judeans under the direction of Mr. Harry Grossman. The paper had an optimistic, light note to it. Despite professing that the "leaflet" would print only "what is most important", the second page contained a rather juvenile joke and a recommendation to read a book called "Beggar's Gold" by Ernest Poole.
On the first day of the holiday of Shevuos, June 2, 1922, Beth El held its first confirmation service. The confirmation class consisted of seven young ladies, all approximately sixteen years of age:
That year Beth El engaged Cantor Jacob Mickleman. He had formerly been Cantor of Congregation Sons of Israel and he was to remain Beth El's Cantor until his retirement in 1941. The forerunner of the "Beth El Ball" was a Chanukah Ball held in 1922 sponsored by Beth El in conjunction with the Council of Jewish Women. Until 1933, this annual affair was referred to as the Beth El-Council Ball. Commencing with the fourth annual Ball of 1925, an ad book journal was published. Chairmen of the Ball between the years 1925 and 1949 were some of Camden's leading Jewish personalities: Philip Auerbach, Herman Odlen, Israel Katz, Meyer Sakin, Ben Natal, Albert Melnik, Norman Heine, E. George Aaron, Robert Brest, S. Mortimer Hirshorn, Louis L. Goldman and Irving Levinsky. These gala annual affairs were usually held either at Beth El or the Walt Whitman Hotel. Sometime after 1949, the Beth El Ball took on added meaning by highlighting the members of the Confirmation Class who were formally presented in a cotillion during the course of the evening. Succeeding Morris Handle as president was Louis Berkowitz. Mrs. Philip Auerbach (Rose) became the second President of Sisterhood.
1923-1924 Louis
Berkowitz was reelected President of the Congregation. Mrs. Louis Paletz
became Sisterhood's third president. By
1924, sixty children were enrolled in the daily religious school. An
additional one hundred and fifty attended the Sunday School. A building
fund drive for a main synagogue building was initiated. On the
twenty-second of June, the cornerstone of the new synagogue was laid. At
the cornerstone laying ceremony guest speakers included Rabbi Max Arzt
of Scranton, Pa. and Dr. Julius H. Greenstone.
Beth
El's new synagogue building was to cost $75,000. It was to be a two-story
building, 60 x 60 feet. The new synagogue was completed in time for the
high holidays of 1924. Camden's newspapers described it as the prettiest
and largest synagogue in South Jersey. The building contained 500 seats in
the main sanctuary plus 100 more seats in the balcony. Dedication
of the new synagogue took place on December 14, 1924. Participating in the
ceremonies were Mayor Victor King of Camden, Dr. A. A. Neuman of
Philadelphia's Adath Jeshurun, Judge William M. Lewis of Philadelphia and
Rabbi Samuel Freedman of Beth EI in Philadelphia. Rabbi Grayzel and Cantor
Mickleman officiated at the service. The Cantor was accompanied by a
choir under the direction of Gedalia Rabinowitz. By
the fall of 1924, Beth El's membership numbered more than two hundred
families. The Rabbi's salary was $4,624. The Cantor received the annual
wage of $1500. The janitor's salary was $900. By 1926 the Cantor still
received $1500 but the janitor had been increased to $1128. Beth El's
telephone bill for the year 1923-24 was $48.14. In 1924 Louis Berkowitz and Mrs. Paletz were reelected to their respective offices in the congregation and sisterhood. Isadore "Pete" Herman became president of the Junior-Young People's Auxiliary.
1925 The
pattern for Beth Ers eventual dues structure was proposed in the "Beth
Elite" of May, 1925. An article mentioned "how dreadful it was for the
Rabbi to have had to make an appeal for funds on Rosh Hashonoh", A plan was
described whereby a "lump-sum" payment would include membership dues
and two seats for the High Holidays as well as tuition. Whether this plan was
adopted at that time is not known. The
Beth El Ball Ad Book of 1925 brought in "much needed revenue", These
yearly journals also provide us with some record of the congregation's
activities and carry the tenor of the times as well. In the 1925 ad book there
appeared a half page ad from a fuel oil burner company with the message,
"Whose hands will shovel your coal next winter?" In the 1926 book, an
ad read, "Park your car at the Ferries, Penna, and Reading," Benjamin Natal succeeded Louis Berkowitz as president of the congregation. Mrs. Louis Paletz was reelected as sisterhood's president.
Members
of the Confirmation Class of 1925 were:
1926 Rabbi Grayzel was apparently disillusioned with the "profitmotive" as the impetus for the Beth El Ball and Journal. In his message for the Journal of 1926, he wrote, "It is a result of the deplorable fact that our synagogues are poorly supported .... shall we not look forward to the time when such gatherings will be called out of motives not of profit, but of a pure desire for joy and festivity." After
seeing Beth El through its incubator period from the Fall of 1921 until June of
1926, Rabbi Solomon Grayzel left Beth El and the rabbinate. During those five
very crucial years, Rabbi Grayzel endeared himself forever to Beth El and the
entire community. His inspiring leadership molded the character of the synagogue
and greatly influenced its future course as a leading conservative synagogue and
great community influence. Upon
leaving Beth El, Rabbi Grayzel went to Europe to continue his studies. He later
received his Doctor of Philosophy degree from Philadelphia's
Dropsie College. From 1929 to 1940, he taught history at Gratz College. In 1933,
he published a book called, "The Church and The Jews in the Thirteenth
Century". In 1962 he became secretary of the AmericanJewish Historical
Society. He was to become one of the great Jewish historians of our times,
attaining the post of editor of the Jewish Publication Society in 1939. He
published his classic "History of the Jews" in 1947. It has become a
universally acclaimed text book. He continues to serve on the faculty of Dropsie
University. Although
Rabbi Grayzel left Beth El in 1926, he was to come back from time to time to
take part in official occasions and to lend his presence to every important
milestone in the congregation's path forward, a path which he so lovingly and
expertly pioneered. In an interview published in the Exponent (1959), he said,
"It was Beth El in Camden that really made a mentsch out of me. I had to
wear a moustache so that they could distinguish me from the children. Imagine
the shyest person in the world. I was it. But they treated me like an oracle.
They agreed with me. They listened. They gave me confidence. Can you imagine
what that meant to a withdrawn religious intellectual like me? I was eternally
grateful" . Rabbi Grayzel was tendered a farewell dinner on October 3, 1926.
Dr.
Cyrus Adler, President of the Jewish Theological Seminary was guest speaker. By
then Beth El's new rabbi was Arthur H. Neulander who served the congregation for
one year. Ben
Natal was reelected to a second term as president of the congregation. Mrs.
Herman Odlen (Clara) became Sisterhood's fourth president. Sometime
in 1926, the first woman ever to speak from Beth El's pulput was a young Zionist
named Goldie Myerson. She had come to Camden to speak about
"Palestine". It would be interesting to know if Israel's Prime
Minister, Golda Meier, recalls her experience at Beth El in 1926. 1927 Rabbi Neulander left Beth El in 1927. He recently retired as Rabbi of the Jewish Center of Bayswater in New York. He is one of the Conservative Rabbinate's leading authorities on Jewish law. He was succeeded at Beth El by Rabbi Nachman S. Arnoff. Rabbi Arnoff, Beth El's "bachelor Rabbi", was also a graduate of the Jewish Theological Seminary. He had spent eight months living and studying in Jerusalem before coming to Camden.
1928 In 1928 the Synagogue's bulletin, The Beth-Elite acquired its current title, The Beth El News. A new publication appeared on the Jewish scene in Camden called "The Community Observer." The first issue appeared in May of 1928. Rabbi Arnoff was listed as Editor; Ben Cohen-Co Editor, Reba Obus and Lillian Grass-News Editors; Carl Auerbach-Business Manager, and Leon Mickleman-Circulation Manager.
There
is evidence pointing to High Holiday services for children being held in the
Beth HamedreshChapel of Beth El. The Community Observer contained an item in
its first issue telling that young Bobby Galanter had a perfect prayer in Hebrew
School for the month of April. Despite the pending national economic crisis Beth El's members contributed generously towards their synagogue. At a Board of Directors meeting, when it was revealed that the Synagogue was in the throes of a financial crisis due to a nine thousand dollar deficit, within a matter of minutes seven thousand dollars was raised amongst the Board MeIJ1bers. In November of 1928, Rabbi Arnoff gave a sermon at a Friday Night Service called, "Can Peace Be Maintained With a Big Stick- a criticism of President Coolidge's Armistice Address." The members of the Mizpah Lodge were scheduled to attend the service "as a body". Mizpah Lodge to this day includes many of Beth El's outstanding members. In
November of that year Jacob Leventon became President of the Congregation. The
installation was accompanied by a banquet at which Dr. Grayzel and a Doctor
Benjamin H. Bernbaum, Rabbi of Boston's Adath Jeshurun Synagogue were the guest
speakers. Mrs. Obus continued on as Sisterhood President.
Because of economic conditions, the Beth El News was mimeographed instead of printed. The practice of reading the names of the "Yahrzeits" at Friday night service began in 1929. In the Beth El News of May 1929, there is a note about plans for a summer school in which Hebrew would be taught three times a week in addition to a recreational program in nearby parks. In the Community Observer of November 1, 1929, there is mention of a High School Department being started at Beth El, "mainly for the boys and girls who have been confirmed at Beth El". Jacob
Leventon was reelected to the presidency of the Congregation, as Mrs. Obus
continued to serve as Sisterhood president. Congregation
Beth Israel was organized in East Camden. The Twenties come to an End Sisterhood's early activities already showed great evidence of the dominant role they would play in Beth El's history. Fund raising, gifts to the children at holiday times, putting on plays, equipping the kitchen, decorating the Sukkah and the synagogue, serving "a tea" following the Friday night service, presenting scholarships to the religious school, supporting the Jewish Theological Seminary (Sisterhood joined the Women's League of the United Synagogue at their third meeting in 1921) were but some of their activities in that first decade. Sisterhood's first annual indoor Bazaar started in 1929 and was to continue for many years. It was in Beth El's first decade that organizations and activities of great variety began. Boy Scout Troop 18 was organized- the Shalesh Sudos- the Beth El Book Club- a Junior Hadassah. The synagogue became the center of every important Jewish activity and fund-raising project. The Hebrew Free Loan Society, a Federation drive, a Zionist Organization, a Hebrew Ladies Charity which was in charge of needy cases and lodging and board for the stranger, Council of Jewish Women, a Junior League, B'Nai Brith, AZA. All these were interwoven with Beth El and drew their leadership from South Jersey's most rapidly growing synagogue. The decade ended on a sad note for World Jewry when the horror of the Arab pogroms in Palestine became known. Under the chairmanship of one of Beth El's most esteemed leaders, Attorney Leon H. Rose, an emergency committee raised four thousand dollars to send to Palestine. Again Mr. Leventon and Mrs. Obus were chosen to retain their presidential offices as the decade of the thirties began. The members of the Confirmation Class of 1929 were:
1930 Stephen S. Wise visited Camden and delivered a "stirring eulogy" of American's wartime president, Woodrow Wilson .... The Community Observer mentioned a reorganization of Camden's Federation of Jewish Charities, Beth Elite, Abraham Furman was elected president .... Sisterhood's Bazaar raised over $1,000 in two nights Tillie Evantash and Abraham Cutler had parts in the Beth EI School's Chanukah program .... Meyer Sakin was chairman of the Beth El Ball .... Sisterhood began sponsoring a Saturday afternoon Story Hour for the children. Jacob Leventon was re-elected to a third term as president of Beth El. Mrs. I.S. Siris (Anne) became Sisterhood president. Members
of the Confirmation Although
Beth El had been organized in 1920, the tenth anniversary was celebrated
by Sisterhood at a special meeting on December 7,1931. The meeting was
held in conjunction with Hadassah and Council of Jewish Women. Guest
speaker was Dr. Israel H. Leventhal of New York's Brooklyn Jewish Center.
He was the son of Philadelphia's "Chief Rabbi", Bernard
Leventhal, one of American Jewry's renown Orthodox leaders. The
"tenth" anniversary was also commemorated at the Friday night
services on December 11. Rabbi Grayzel was the guest speaker. The
anniversary festivities were climaxed at a banquet on December 13. Mr. Leventon and Mrs. Siris were re-elected to office. The
Confirmation Class of 1931
1932
1933 Despite economic
conditions, Kol Nidre appeals were still conducted. Contributions of
three dollars were greatly appreciated. There existed in Camden at that
time, a Jewish Welfare Society that set a $3,500 goal in 1933. Ben Natal, writing
in the Beth El Ball Journal that
year, said "in these days of depression an evening spent in merriment
and diversion will relieve us of that morbid feeling and bring back hope
for a bright future." In October of that
year, five adult education courses were offered. A Forum Series was
presented featuring Maurice Samuel, Professor Mordecai Kaplan, Reverend
John Haynes Holmes, and Professor Harry Overstreet. The Forum was
officially called "The Program Committee." It was a joint effort
with Hadassah and Council of Jewish Women. Rabbi Arnoff also gave a series
of Sunday morning lectures. Joseph S. Kaplan
became President of. the Beth El League.
Mr. Barroway
and Mrs. Abramson continued as Presidents of Congregation and
Sisterhood. Norman Heine again became President of the Council of Jewish
Juniors.
1934 December
16th, 1934 marked the annual dinner and installation of officers. At the affair
the program featured the Beth EI Choir consisting of Mrs. Maurice Russell
(Sadie), Joseph Becker, Samuel Gordon, and Harry Silver under the direction of
Cantor Mickleman. We also find reference to a Zionist youth group called "Gordoniah"
led by their President, Ben Zion Steinberg. Israel Katz became Beth El's new
President. Mrs. Morris (Esther Quint) Rabkin was elected Sisterhood President.
Morris Albert succeeded Norman Heine as Council of Jewish Juniors President.
1935 Sometime before the Spring of 1935 Rabbi Amoff left Beth El. His future was unfortunately short lived. He became a Chaplain in the United States Army during World War II and was killed in an army truck accident following his discharge at Fort Kilmer. A memorial service was held for him at Beth El on September 22, 1946. Beth El's search for a new rabbi ended when Rabbi Philip Lipis spoke at the synagogue on Friday night, March 22, 1935. He was officially elected to the pulpit in April. In his letter of acceptance, he wrote, "I pray that my election as rabbi of Beth El in this Passover season of freedom may bring to Beth EI freedom from inertia and a rebirth of activity and service, Jewish and human." Rabbi
Lipis had been ordained at the Jewish Theological Seminary in 1930 and had been
rabbi of Emmanuel Congregation in Oak Lane, Philadelphia. During his first five
years at Beth El he was to greatly revitalize the Forum Series, organize a Men's
Club, the Alumni, the Tephillin Club, a Junior Congregation, the Special Fund, a
Hebrew High School Class (1938), and the Institute of Jewish Studies. Jesse Satenstein became president of the congregation. Mrs. Ben Natal (Minnie) again took Sisterhood's highest office. Carl Auerbach became president of the Council of Jewish Juniors.
The Confirmation class of 1935 included:
1936 The
Beth El Journal contained a special tribute to the memory of Philip Auerbach,
"sincere, earnest, indefatigable"" chairman of the Beth El Ball
Committee since its inception. Mr.
Jesse Satenstein and Mrs. Ben
Natal were re-elected to head the congregation and sisterhood. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||